You are here

Is Tobacco Haram? Eric Walberg and “One Cigarette Per Day”

Editor’s introduction:
Most Islamic scholars today consider tobacco haram. The two leading reasons are:

1) The Harm Principle (Qur’an 2:195 – “Do not throw yourselves into destruction”)

  • Smoking is proven to cause cancer, heart disease, and premature death.

  • Based on this, many scholars now consider it haram due to its clear and significant harm to the body, which violates the Islamic principle of preserving life.

2)  Wastefulness (Israf – Qur’an 7:31)

  • Money spent on cigarettes is seen as wasteful, especially since it brings no benefit.

  • The Qur’an warns against extravagance and squandering resources.

Additionally, Usul-al-fiqh methods cite two other factors that might be subsumed under the harm principle:

  • Sadd al-dharā’iʿ (blocking the means): Tobacco leads to addiction and serious health problems.

  • Hifz al-nafs (preservation of life): One of the five maqāṣid (objectives) of the Shari‘ah.

Eric Walberg’s defense of very light smoking (one cigarette per day) is obviously not a legal opinion. But it raises questions, including: Since the harmfulness and wastefulness of smoking depends on the amount being smoked, with one cigarette per day being less harmful and wasteful than all sorts of perfectly non-haram activities (such as eating more and worse than is optimal for health, or driving a car when one could be walking or biking) how does fiqh reconcile the apparent contradiction?
Feel free to leave a comment at the Al-Andalus Tribune Substack.
-Editor

Tobacco – Death sentence with perks

By Eric Walberg….

Posted by 

Related posts

Leave a Comment